Great thread idea SD, hopefully we'll get a fair few reports in the same place!
I had a great day, I brought my trusty Isengard list along that was a smaller version of my TOS list, army as follows:
Vrasku - Leader
6 Uruk Hai Crossbowmen
Shaman
9 Feral Uruk Hai
Uruk Hai Pikeman
Orc with spear
(the pikeman and spearman were there to fill up the last 16 points I had, not for any devious tactical reason)
Game 1 - To the Death V Sam McGuiness' Rohan
Sam had an absolutely gorgeous Rohan army consisting of Grimbold and Gamling leading about 10 Helmingas with shields, 5 Helmingas with Throwing spears and 6 Royal Guard with Throwing spears. I chose the oath where I had to kill more troops with missile fire than he did. I fancied my chances with this one as I'd done well against Rohan in the practice games, first few turns were uneventful as he approached me and my crossbows failed to do anything (frustrating for my oath). Thankfully on the turn before we clashed I took down 3 Royal Guard in 1 round of shooting, although I had a nervous moment as he was able to get about 8 throwing spear shots on Vrasku, thankfully Fate and Fury kept him alive. As soon as the battle lines met it swung in my favour, Ferals and Royal Guard are the same points but I had 2 attacks and my S4 negated his D6 and I was able to get a fairly solid win when I took down Gamling. The highlight was when I realised that we were tied on shooting casualties as we started the last turn, desperate to get my oath I charged 1 crossbowman into a Helminga and then fired into the combat with another crossbowman and Vrasku, Vrasku had to use his last 2 remaining Might to wound the Helminga but down he went, gaining me the 3 VPs and, more importantly, the 2 TPs you gained for completing an oath. Most fantastically, the crossbowman in the combat survived! So a win and a completed oath to start but more importantly a great game agains a really nice guy.
Game 2 - Domination V Steve
This was only Steve's third game of SBG so I had something of an advantage but he also had an Isengard army which countered many of my strengths (S4 shooting, same F value). I chose the hardcore leader oath and rolled a 6 - the maximum
Vrasku would have to kill 6 enemies throughout the game. Things started badly for me when Steve gained his oath (he had to kill my shaman) with some crazy shooting in turn 2; he fired 3 crossbow bolts that went through a feral and then through a crossbowman, 2 out of 3 wounded my shaman, he failed his channelled Fury and then failed his fate and was dead - horrific! The game was cagey for a few turns as we manoeuvred for position but eventually he sent his 12 shield/pike uruks forwards led by a captain whilst Vrasku and his crossbowmen took up a defensive position in some ruins. Unfortunately for Steve this allowed my to gang up on his 1 warband with my whole army and again my ferals carried the day. He was then broken and in dire need of some victory points so sent 1 crossbowman to grab each of the three nearest objectives, pulling them away from Vrasku's stand fast, unfortunately he then failed 2 of their courage rolls leaving me with a solid victory but no oath (Vrasku had a bad game and was only able to kill 4 enemies).
Game 3 - High Ground V Mark Searle
By this point I had reached the giddy heights of table 2 and came up against Mark's army of Thranduil, Legolas and about 11 Wood Elves. I felt pretty good about this game as I'd done well against Wood elves in the practice games and my crossbows should take a heavy toll on his D3 elves - my oath was to kill Legolas, his was to kill Vrasku. Mark sensibly deployed far away from the hill to maximise his shooting and we traded a few turns of relatively uneventful shooting. He channelled Thranduil's Nature's Wrath but thankfully only killed 2 ferals as a result. I was then able to overwhelm Thranduil's warband and kill him (his leader). By this point Legolas had made a bid for the hill with about 6 elves and the filthy elf prince killed both Vrasku and my shaman with bowfire, this killed my leader, gained Mark his oath and, far more importantly, ended my Fury. Despite my setbacks we were both broken and I had more models on the hill than him, if we rolled a 1 or a 2 to end the game I would probably win, I rolled the dice - A 4! On we went...Sadly, I then had the most outrageous bad luck with my courage tests and, along with some crossbowmen, about 3 of my C5 ferals legged it! the numbers on the hill had thus swung heavily in Mark's favour and the next turn he rolled a 1 and ended the game with a convincing win for Mark. So close! Sadly, I'd not only lost but failed to achieve my oath (I should've picked Thranduil) and so went from an impressive 12/14 TPS to a far more depressing 12/21 and went tumbling down the tables. It was a really fun game played in a good spirit though and Mark was a really friendly guy so no complaints.
Game 4 - Lords of Battle V Suicidal Marsbar
Hee, it's interesting writing this having read Marabar's account above and he summed it up quite well! He was a really nice guy but clearly not in the best state and was seemingly suffering from the hangover from hell. As a result the game was over relatively quickly, I got pretty lucky inflicting 2 wounds on his Warg Marauder with crossbow fire which made it easier to take down in combat and his decision to hide his uruks meant I could deal with his goblin warband without too much trouble, when he broke the game ended straight away and Marsbar legged it outside
I was also lucky to achieve what I thought was the hardest oath 'do not break' so back to my winning ways although clearly against an opponent who was not at full power! He was a lovely guy though and I'm sure the result could have been very different were it not for the Wargraine!
By this point I'd moved back up to table 3. The 2 guys playing on table 1 had won 4 games so first place was probably out of reach but there were only about 3 or 4 of us on 3 wins so 2nd place was still very much up for grabs with an outside chance of 1st depending on how the oaths, sportsmanship and best army points went...
Game 5 - Reconnoitre V RunePriestRidcully
For my last game I was up against a Numenorian captain with 5 warriors of Numenor and Erestor with about 12 High Elves. My oath was to reduce Erestor to 1 wound or 0 Fate and at this stage of the competition I knew how crucial those oath points would be. I think RPR made a slight error in judgement here as he sent about 15 of his troops running for the edge and completely avoided my army, I was able to pick off about 4 of them with crossbow bolts meaning that he got 11 models off very early on. Most frustratingly for me was that one of those models was Erestor and as he legged it he took any chance of me completing my oath with him. Whilst it seemed RPR was heavily in the lead, he now only had 4 elf archers against my whole force. To be fair they put up quite a fight (High fight value and an awful lot of 6s) but they were eventually overwhelmed and I was able to move most of my army off for a 15-11 victory. The more I play it the more I think Reconnoitre is the hardest scenario to get your tactics right, particularly for small armies, I find it's very, very hard to win against a horde army.
And that was that, all in all I'd managed:
4 wins
1 loss
2/5 completed oaths
for a TP total of 24/35
I also got 2/5 sportsmanship votes which gave me 4 bonus points.
I knew my 4 wins should place me well but 2/5 oaths wasn't great and who knew what affect sportsmanship would have?
In the end Jamie quite rightly won the tournament by 5 clear points (he was the only player to win all 5 games), my round 3 opponent Mark was second and I managed a very respectable...4th!
Perhaps the most galling thing about the whole tournament was that my arch rival Tom Harrison has pipped me to 3rd by, once agin, being the nicest guy in the world and getting 3 most sporting votes and ending up with 1 point more than me despite only winning 3 games! I would hasten to add in these forums where you can't read/hear emotion that I say this in complete jest, Tom is a very good friend of mine and I fully believe you should be rewarded for sportsmanship, I just knew I wouldn't hear the end of it in the pub
Looking at the results if I'd completed one more oath I would have tied 2nd place for TPs and won it on VPs, if only Vrasku had killed 2 more guys in game 2, if only I'd picked Thranduil instead of Legolas in Game 3, if only I'd wounded Erestor in Game 5, if only, if only...
Final thoughts
All in all it was a great day and I was thoroughly chuffed to get 4 wins and a couple of sportsmanship awards. The 300 points limit was great and showed how well the ruleset works at low points levels, it was also nice to see many of the 'competitive' no-brainers (wizards, shades, spider queens etc.) absent due to their prohibitive points cost. Great to meet up with some fellow One-Ringers and peeps from Nottingham and the whole event was really well run. Once again my Ferals were game winners, reaffirming my belief that they're amongst the best troops in the game, I'm amazed you don;t see more of them.
Massive thanks to Marsbar for the great idea of a small tournament and to Damian and Chris for organising, particularly to Chris for managing to get all the results input and ranked in the tight turnaround between games as well as playing in the tourney - no easy task!
We then all retired to the pub for a few debrief pints (and the obligatory ribbing from Harrison) and watched the hour long preview of the Desolation of Smaug on my iPad - perfect end to the perfect day!
Well done all who attended, can't wait for the next one!