The One Ring https://wap.one-ring.co.uk/ |
|
"Balancing" War of the Ring https://wap.one-ring.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=88&t=22069 |
Page 1 of 1 |
Author: | Chris GoM [ Sun Dec 11, 2011 9:10 pm ] |
Post subject: | "Balancing" War of the Ring |
In my attempt to "balance" War of the Ring I've spent some time adjusting Point Values and a few of the main rules, as I feel that the rules for War of the Ring are good, but the points needed to be adjusted Changes to the Rules: Epic Strike adds 2 to the Hero’s Fight Value, instead of increasing it to 10. Wings of Terror increase the formations move and charge distance by 2” instead of increasing it up to move 12”, charge D6 + 8”. Strength from Corruption does D3 automatic hits against enemy formations, instead of D6, although it still does D6 automatic hits to friendly formations as normal. Pall of Night only stops enemy units charging on a role of 6. Counsellor may only be used once per Hero per turn. Crossbows may not At the Double! and use a Heroic Shoot. Overlord may only be used by a formation that contains a Hero or Epic Hero. A role of “1” always fails, even with bonuses. Changes to the Points: All Banner Bearers cost 25 points instead of 35. All Horn-blowers and Drummers costs 10 points instead of 15. All Taskmasters cost 20 points instead of 25. All Captains, Chieftains or similarly named Heroes Points costs is now based on the following: Fight 2/3: 25 Points instead of 50. Fight 4: 30 Points instead of 50. Fight 5: 35 Points instead of 50. Fight 6: 40 Points instead of 50. Fight 7: 45 Points instead of 50. Army Specific Changes: Gondor and Arnor: All formations of Minas Tirith Warriors cost 30 Points instead of 25. All formations of Warriors of the Dead cost 50 Points instead of 60. All formations of Riders of the Dead cost 50 Points instead of 60. Forlong the Fat costs 50 Points instead of 75. Angbor the Fearless costs 50 Points instead of 75. Osgiliath Veterans cost 95 Points + 35 per company instead of 120 Points + 35 per company. Denethor’s Guard cost 85 Points + 35 per company instead of 120 Points + 35 per company. Court of the Dead King cost 115 Points + 50 per company instead of 145 Points + 30 per company. Bonuses may not be not be taken for both Narsil and Anduril if both are in one formation; the user must choose which applies. The Kingdom of Rohan: The King’s Guard cost 80 Points + 35 per company instead of 100 Points + 35 per company. Erkenbrand’s Riders cost 95 Points + 40 per company instead of 115 Points + 40 per company. Théodred’s Knights cost 90 Points + 40 per company instead of 135 Points + 45 per company. Grimbold’s Helmingas cost 60 Points + 30 per company instead of 85 Points + 30 per company. Elfhelm’s Riders cost 75 Points + 35 per company instead of 90 Points + 40 per company. The Elven Kingdoms: All formations of Galadhrim Regiments cost 40 Points instead of 45. All formations of Galadhrim Archer Regiments cost 45 Points instead of 50. All formations of High Elf Regiments cost 50 Points instead of 55. All formations of High Elf Archer Regiments cost 55 Points instead of 60. All formations of High Elf Cohorts cost 55 Points instead of 60. All formations of Guards of the Galadhrim Court cost 60 Points instead of 70. High Elf Commanders (High Elf Cohort Hero) cost 55 Points instead of 50. Elven Stormcallers cost 65 Points instead of 100. Rivendell Guard cost 85 Points + 60 per company instead of 125 Points + 65 per company. Guardians of Caras Galadhon cost 105 Points + 60 per company instead of 125 Points + 70 per company The Dwarf Holds: Múrin’s Guard costs 95 Points + 45 per company instead of 110 Points + 40. Drár’s Hunters costs 65 Points + 40 per company instead of 95 Points + 35. Durin’s Guard costs 165 Points + 50 per company instead of 110 Points + 50. The Forgotten Kingdoms: Ents cost 115 Points instead of 125. Eagles cost 125 Points instead of 140. Treebeard costs cost 205 points instead of 225. Gwaihir costs 175 Points instead of 200. If Radagast uses Epic Tranquillity then his formation may not charge in addition to the current effects. Mordor: All formations of Morannon Orc Warbands cost 25 Points instead of 20. Mordor Trolls cost 90 Points instead of 100. Mordor Troll Drummers cost 130 Points instead of 150. Mordor Troll Chieftains cost 175 Points instead of 200. Twilight Ringwraiths cost 125 Points instead of 150. Kârdush the Firecaller costs 80 points instead of 100. Gothmog costs 135 Points instead of 110. Gollum costs 35 Points instead of 50. Orc Shamans cost 55 Points instead of 100. Black Uruk Shamans cost 60 Points instead of 100. Shagrat’s Tower Guard costs 100 Points + 25 per company instead of 125 Points + 25. Gorbag’s Morgul Rats costs 90 Points + 15 per company instead of 125 Points + 15 per company. Grishnákh’s Trackers costs 60 Points + 30 per company instead of 75 Points + 30 per company. Winged Nazgûl cost 220 Points instead of 250. The Fortress of Isengard: Isengard Trolls cost 90 Points instead of 100. Isengard Troll Chieftains cost 130 Points instead of 150. Orc Shamans cost 55 Points instead of 100. Uruk-Hai Shamans cost 60 Points instead of 100. Uglúk’s Raiders costs 80 Points + 35 per company instead of 115 Points + 30 per company. Vrashkû’s Talons costs 65 Points + 40 per company instead of 95 Points + 35 per company. Mauhúr’s Marauders costs 80 Points + 35 per company instead of 100 Points + 30 per company. Thrydan Wolfsbane costs 60 Points instead of 50. Saruman the White Hand costs 215 Points instead of 240. The Misty Mountains: Goblin Shamans cost 55 Points instead of 100. All formations of Gundabad Blackshields cost 25 Points instead of 20. Any summoned Formations that wished to be used for Drûzhag the Beastcallers “Summon Beasts” special rule must be paid for. However this does not require Might Points. The Fallen Realms: Corsair Bo’suns cost 35 Points instead of 50. Hâsharin cost 40 Points instead of 50. All formations of Corsair Raiding Party’s have Thrown Weapons that have a Strength value of 2. Easterling War Priests cost 60 Points instead of 100. Mahûd Raider Warbands may be given Lances for 5 Points per company. Passives only grant shield bonuses from shooting attacks (including magic attacks in their front arc). Abrakhân Guard costs 70 Points + 30 per company instead of 100 Points + 30 per company. Angmar: Orc Shamans cost 55 Points instead of 100. All formations of Ghostly Legion cost 50 Points instead of 60. All formations of Ghostly Riders cost 50 Points instead of 60. All formations of Spectral Hosts cost 50 Points instead of 60. All formations of Court of Fallen Kings may be joined by any Epic Hero that is a Spirit. Ringwraiths: Ringwraiths cost 140 Points instead of 125. There are Nine may be taken as an upgrade for the following points (if nine Ringwraiths and/or Winged Nazgûl, one must be the Witch-King of Angmar): The Witch-King of Angmar – 75 Points Khamûl the Easterling – 60 Points The Undying – 15 Points The Tainted – 15 Points The Dark Marshal – 25 Points The Shadow Lord – 20 Points The Dwimmerlaik – 30 Points The Betrayer – 50 Points The Knight of Umbar – 25 Points. This was a word document previously, I've just copy and pasted it from there, the name of each unit was previously in italics. If you want the word document, just pm me your email and I'll send it to you Comments and Criticism please |
Author: | Beowulf03809 [ Mon Dec 12, 2011 12:12 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
Just looking thru a few and have a quick question: Under the Elves you seem to have tweaked the normal warriors for everything except Wood Elves. Was there a reason? |
Author: | Bastion.HUN [ Mon Dec 12, 2011 12:30 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
I agree with the epic stike modifycation. What is your problem with this: "Crossbows may not At the Double! and use a Heroic Shoot". I think they are a strong unit, and usually slow cause of their weapons, but it is no impossible to defeat them. |
Author: | WayUnderTheMountain [ Mon Dec 12, 2011 1:23 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
I suggest looking at Xelee's houserules. They are concise but fairly effective at balancing the game without re-writing the entire rule book (or in this case, a lot of rules and costs for formations). I will keep these rules in mind though for my next game of WotR so my gaming group might consider conducting some field tests of our own. |
Author: | Xelee [ Mon Dec 12, 2011 1:33 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
Hi Chris GoM, what springs out at me when I see that list is that it almost seems made for a new army spreadsheet as a device to handle the changes (this goes for a number of other sets that have taken this approach too). You could even edit the existing one by just altering units to your new values? |
Author: | Slythar [ Mon Dec 12, 2011 1:47 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
Like A role of “1” always fails, even with bonuses. I like a natural 1 is always a miss. I've used it on and off but generally if you roll a 1, you shouldn't be rewarded with anything. Drûzhag the Beastcallers “Summon Beasts” I thought of this as well and it allows Druzag to summon beasts held in reserve. But it still costs a might point. Aragorns Epic Journey is similiar and it costs 2 might, plus they cannot shoot or charge. Still a cheesy rule. Don't Like Dirt cheap casters It can be a problem. A couple shades or Dwimmerlaik and its not likely they will ever face a duel so evil just got a whole lot deadlier. If Epic Hero's didn't have spells I think you would still see the 100 point casters taken. For simplicity sakes I would make captains cost the same either at a set value or formula (5pts per fight). That's one line and can eliminate a page of information. Nice work all-around. Its quite the undertaking. |
Author: | Chris GoM [ Mon Dec 12, 2011 7:32 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
I've updated the rules (see first post) Thank you all for your comments, I will make adjustments where I think you've made good points. Beowulf03809 wrote: Just looking thru a few and have a quick question: Under the Elves you seem to have tweaked the normal warriors for everything except Wood Elves. Was there a reason? Wood Elves have Enchanted cloaks, which I think makes up for their low defence, don't forget that if the enemy is close enough to charge them, then it's likely they'll be able to use their throwing daggers. Bastion.HUN wrote: I agree with the epic stike modifycation. What is your problem with this: "Crossbows may not At the Double! and use a Heroic Shoot". I think they are a strong unit, and usually slow cause of their weapons, but it is no impossible to defeat them. Crossbows can still move normally and use a Heroic Shoot, but I feel that if they could At the Double and then Heroic shoot then they'd easily be able to shoot an enemy in the flank, negating any shield bonuses and making it too easy to kill. Don't forget only Evil armies have access to Crossbows, so Good can't even ally them in. WayUnderTheMountain wrote: I suggest looking at Xelee's houserules. They are concise but fairly effective at balancing the game without re-writing the entire rule book (or in this case, a lot of rules and costs for formations). I will keep these rules in mind though for my next game of WotR so my gaming group might consider conducting some field tests of our own. I have seen Xelee's house rules, which is where I got the idea for the Epic Strike. Xelee wrote: Hi Chris GoM, what springs out at me when I see that list is that it almost seems made for a new army spreadsheet as a device to handle the changes (this goes for a number of other sets that have taken this approach too). You could even edit the existing one by just altering units to your new values? I hadn't really thought about spreadsheets when I designed these rules. Slythar wrote: Like A role of “1” always fails, even with bonuses. I like a natural 1 is always a miss. I've used it on and off but generally if you roll a 1, you shouldn't be rewarded with anything. Drûzhag the Beastcallers “Summon Beasts” I thought of this as well and it allows Druzhag to summon beasts held in reserve. But it still costs a might point. Aragorns Epic Journey is similiar and it costs 2 might, plus they cannot shoot or charge. Still a cheesy rule. Don't Like Dirt cheap casters It can be a problem. A couple shades or Dwimmerlaik and its not likely they will ever face a duel so evil just got a whole lot deadlier. If Epic Hero's didn't have spells I think you would still see the 100 point casters taken. For simplicity sakes I would make captains cost the same either at a set value or formula (5pts per fight). That's one line and can eliminate a page of information. Nice work all-around. Its quite the undertaking. Thank you. I hadn't thought about using a formula, I just went through the rulebook and looked at the different rules for Captains, Chieftains etc. Will update the rules in a bit. Again, thank you all for taking the time to post. |
Author: | Mighty.Uruk!!! [ Tue Dec 13, 2011 7:30 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
ah brilliant. i love the idea of putting up the costs of the ringwraiths! such a simple thing but means people cannot have as many ringwraiths in one small army |
Author: | Chris GoM [ Wed Dec 14, 2011 3:54 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
Thanks Might.Uruk!!! I must admit I've used Khamul and the Betrayer at the same time in multiple 1000 Points games, and I've seen the devastation they've caused, as well as a few of the other Ringwraiths. |
Author: | GothmogtheWerewolf [ Thu Dec 15, 2011 12:30 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
May I ask, why have you reduced Ghosts a little, but not Spectres when they are much much much worse for their pts, they shouldn't cost motre than 35-40pts at absolute max. |
Author: | Chris GoM [ Thu Dec 15, 2011 4:25 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: "Balancing" War of the Ring |
GothmogtheWerewolf wrote: May I ask, why have you reduced Ghosts a little, but not Spectres when they are much much much worse for their pts, they shouldn't cost motre than 35-40pts at absolute max. Thanks for spotting that. Spectres aren't much worse than Ghosts, just over-pointed. I personally prefer Spectres over Ghosts, because Fight Value makes little difference, and their slightly lower defence is nullified by their special rule and the use of dismay spells |
Page 1 of 1 | All times are UTC |
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |