All times are UTC


It is currently Thu Dec 12, 2024 4:38 am



Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 3 posts ] 
Author Message
 Post subject: White Dwarf Content Questions
PostPosted: Sat Mar 02, 2013 12:01 am 
Craftsman
Craftsman
User avatar
Offline

Joined: Sat Mar 20, 2010 8:58 am
Posts: 351
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Hi all, I posted this synopsis in another post, but I'm keen to know what bits people like from the White Dwarf magazines just for my own interest.

Here's a brief synopsis of the March 2013 mag (essentially the same stuff as has been in the previous few):

Pages 1-49 = catalogue, with gorgeous photos and some description, but still just a catalogue of what's available to buy this month.
Pages 50-55 = army of the month.
Pages 56-57 = Jervis' column.
Pages 58-73 = Battle report (not as detailed as they used to be, but with bigger better pictures, not even points listed).
Pages 74-77 = Blanchitsu, if you like his style I guess you'd like these pages.
Pages 78-79 = Hall of fame, one page pic, other page a blurb about a particular model.
Pages 80-95 = Slayer sword etc. competition pictures (you can see them on the internet if you want).
Pages 96-101 = kitbash (though rarely anything more than just using bitz rather than the olden days of plasticard and how-to guides, it's really just pics of a few models).
Pages 102-109 = Armies on Parade pics, again, something you can find on the internet, hardly any word descriptions at all.
Pages 110 - 117 = Paint splatter, showing some colour guides etc.
Pages 118 - 119 = Jeremy Vetock's column.
Pages 120 - 137 = GW store listings, subscription details etc.
Pages 138 - 151 = what the various teams have been up to (some of which is more catalogue type stuff about new things).
The End.

I'll let you work out just how much of this is worth your time, but you can see that a full 1/3 of it is pure catalogue. There is a lot of stuff that you can internet find anyway, or is just pure pictures (about 30 pages).

Personally, I quite like battle reports (though I like more information). I also quite like the Paint splatter sections when they have helpful tips like how to do faces/eyes/writing etc. The Army of the Month I like to look at, though I guess the internet sort of does that too.

In all there's probably about 20-30 pages I really like and another of about the same that I don't mind too much. That still leaves a lot of magazine that I could do without and would much rather have more actual hobby/gaming content rather than just big long descriptions and pics of new releases.

My subscription is a birthday present, so I guess I'm not super involved like some people are who spend hard earned dosh on it.

So what are your thoughts?

_________________
My LotR and 40k blog, Realm of Battle board, dwarves, gobs, space wolves and battle reports. http://simbattleboard.blogspot.com/
Top
  Profile  
Reply with quote  
 Post subject: Re: White Dwarf Content Questions
PostPosted: Sat Mar 02, 2013 5:48 pm 
Craftsman
Craftsman
User avatar
Offline

Joined: Mon Jun 25, 2012 8:01 pm
Posts: 453
Location: Honiton, East Devon - In my base, shooting your doodz.
Well, as a retailer rather than a hobbyist on this one here are my thoughts. I don't pay for my White Dwarves either - perhaps one of the few perks of working many unsocial hours for very low turnout and having to motivate myself to complete each day's tasks xD But enough of self-employment, more onto White Dwarf.

Before I delve into breaking the magazine apart and giving my thoughts, I'd like to say something that gets said almost every day in Green Dragon HQ. They use photoshop. Or something similar, either way it is glaringly obvious when you take a look at White Dwarf that they touch up the pictures of the models to make the paint jobs seem as perfect as they can, there are no laws as far as I know to stop them doing this but it makes it difficult for guys like Dead Marshes and our painting service when the actual models, whilst they still look amazing in real life, can never have the contrast and airbrushedness that the photos in White Dwarf do. They have a dedicated team of people working on this to achieve that glossy, jaw-dropping look. This is because White Dwarf is distributed world-wide and is almost a front-runner to the hobby in stores like WH Smith and most good newsagents. That annoyance out of the way, lets delve in.

Pages 1-49 = catalogue, For me this is key, I know many people don't like this as it is just a glorified advert on whats new but this is essential. As the wargaming business revolves around whats new I usually tear open the delivery and dig out White Dwarf to find out exactly whats going online on the Friday night. Sure Games Workshop send me prices and a brief bit of info, but I need the full descriptions, pictures and to find out what you get in the box. I love it, and I can't wait to see what they surprise us with next month!

Pages 50-55 = army of the month. Very much hit and miss for me, this is where I go back to being a hobbyist but 9 times out of 10 I tend to flick through unless its an army I collect. A nice feature to get my fill of minis though and I'd rather they keep this and do away with the Golden Demon fluff, more on that later.

Pages 56-57 = Jervis' column. Of the two columns in the mag this is my second favourite, still usually quite a good read and I always agree with his views on keeping the hobby fun. As a matter of fact I rated March's article quite high as he reminded me that dice rolls can solve all and helped me with designing my Hobbit campaign.

Pages 58-73 = Battle report (not as detailed as they used to be, but with bigger better pictures, not even points listed). At first I was glad they aren't as detailed as I used to find them a struggle to read when it was say Chaos Warriors vs Lizardmen or something, two armies I don't and will never collect. So its good to get the summary when it is a game I wouldn't have much interest in, however on the whole I think they shouldn't have changed the format. Points values is essential for hobbyists like us, the fact they just throw together whatever they want almost shows a disregard to the very rules they designed. The Hobbit battle report back in November was over in a flash, I wanted to know what the dice rolls were, blow by blow what was happening, how did they overcome each challenge. But no, they need to save magazine space for all those adverts.

Pages 74-77 = Blanchitsu - I still don't even know what this is or what purpose it serves. I like the pretty pictures but I find myself skipping this section every issue.

Pages 78-79 = Hall of fame, one page pic, other page a blurb about a particular model. Nothing at all wrong with this, 1-2 pages focusing on a very special model, I see nothing wrong with it and back when they did the C'tan Nightbriner model it inspired a couple of gamers at my club to purchase one and undertake a similar project. This section deserves to be in the magazin.

Pages 80-95 = Slayer sword etc. competition pictures (you can see them on the internet if you want). Get rid of this section. I can see models, made with loving care on this very forum if I like.

Pages 96-101 = kitbash (though rarely anything more than just using bitz rather than the olden days of plasticard and how-to guides, it's really just pics of a few models). - You nailed it with that comment, this section is okay and worth a quick read but I would much prefer if they used more obscure parts and resources to make it more of an interesting project. I think we do better projects on these forums.

Pages 102-109 = Armies on Parade pics, again. Get rid of this section, I skip these pages every month.

Pages 110 - 117 = Paint splatter, showing some colour guides etc. This I find useful and quite enjoy having a read of it. This can stay :)

Pages 118 - 119 = Jeremy Vetock's column. Always worth a read, this guy speaks from the heart as a true hobbyist, his article this month really grabbed me with talking about bits scattering under a table never to be seen again. You can tell this chap is doing it for love not money. Keep this, and give him more space!

Pages 120 - 137 = GW store listings, subscription details etc. SERIOUSLY!? Do they think we can't find this on the internet? 17 pages wasted on self-indulgent adverts. This is why White Dwarf doesn't sell too well.

Pages 138 - 151 = what the various teams have been up to (some of which is more catalogue type stuff about new things). I don't mind this section, its interesting to see how productive the White Dwarf team are and also interesting to have a look at some of the new forgeworld stuff, could be simplified and cut down a bit to save space though.
The End.

There you have it :).

_________________
My Wargaming Store: http://www.greendragongames.co.uk
10-25% off LOTR.

- Model Painting Service also available.
Top
  Profile  
Reply with quote  
 Post subject: Re: White Dwarf Content Questions
PostPosted: Sun Mar 03, 2013 8:54 pm 
Wayfarer
Wayfarer
User avatar
Offline

Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2013 8:52 pm
Posts: 29
Location: Shetland, United Kingdom
Images: 16
Well, to be honest an absolute and utter waste of money, particularly now they are printing on a glossier paper and I am unable to successfully use as a bog-roll substitute..... remember Izal?

Toodle-pip, Mungo

_________________
On The Bench : Metal Easterlings, Metal Serpent Riders
Top
  Profile  
Reply with quote  
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 3 posts ] 

All times are UTC


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 29 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to: